Processing image(s)...
Jan 24th 17:01 • Post #1
Dydia • Los Angeles, CA Post #1
Jan 24th 17:01
Los Angeles, CA

What do you say, and what do you hear others saying? "Argon-mercury" or "Mercury-argon"? How long have you been using the term you use? I'm curious to see which one is more common. Thanks! 


Jan 25th 09:10 • Post #2
Robert • AK Post #2
Jan 25th 09:10

I, too, have often wondered if this was a regional difference or perhaps just a matter of habit and initial learning.  I have, for decades, used the terminology of "Mercury-Argon"  or sometimes even just "mercury" for shorthand if I knew that my audience understood.  

This was most likely born out of how I first heard it referred to, however, it made sense as the Mercury becomes the dominant spectral trait in such a tube and the Argon is mostly just used as the carrier gas to get the ionization going and only contributes a small percentage to the overall UV output to excite the phosphors. 

However, while the same would be true if Neon or another rare gas was used with Mercury, I instead refer to those as "Neon with Mercury" or "Krypton with Mercury" etc.  I did, at one time, ask myself why exactly I would be inconsistent in this regard and I came to the conclusion that my reasoning for the latter examples is simply because it is not a standard and commonly used combination.  Most neon filled units do not have mercury added to them unless you specifically want the color shifting effect from it.  FWIW-- I actually do exactly this in many of my art pieces as I do like the effect, but beyond that, it is not a common practice.  (do note that in cold climates, a mixture with a high percentage of Ne vs Ar is used as the neon will run hotter and help vaporize mercury for better output in phosphor coated tubes when outdoors in winter.....a 75/25 Ne/Ar mixture plus Hg being a common example, although I have seen straight neon used for this purpose too)

So, while that incsonsistency of nomenclature would normally be something that bothers me, I have, over the years, managed to forgive myself for it due to the above line of reasoning even if some may find it flawed.